Florida health care provider settles monopolization, conspiracy claims

Health First, Inc. and its subsidiaries have settled allegations that they attempted to establish a vertically integrated, self-reinforcing, illegally-maintained health care monopoly in Southern Brevard County, Florida. Just days after denying Health First’s motion for summary judgment, the federal district court in Orlando dismissed the antitrust claims with prejudice.

Omni Healthcare, Inc. and other physicians and physician practice groups filed suit against “fully integrated” health care corporation Health First, Inc. and three of its wholly owned subsidiaries: Holmes Regional Medical Center, Inc.; Health First Health Plans, Inc., and Health First Physicians, Inc. Omni alleged that Health First engaged in an anticompetitive scheme to monopolize Southern Brevard County’s interrelated health care markets for years and that the scheme has largely been successful.

The court denied Health First summary judgment on August 13, 2016, finding that Omni and other physicians and physician groups created genuine issues of material fact in whether Health First monopolized, attempted to monopolize, and conspired to monopolize the markets for physician services, Medicare Advantage, and ancillary services.