Highlight on Illinois: Exchange rates rise in the Land of Lincoln

Illinois residents purchasing individual health insurance plans through the Patient Protection and Affordable Care (ACA) (P.L. 111-148) could pay rate increases in 2017 as high as 55 percent, according to rate information released by the Illinois Department of Insurance (DOI). The agency submitted rate increases to the federal government ranging from 43 percent to 55 percent, depending on the type of plan—bronze, silver, gold.

Filings

The submitted rates are not final. Although the DOI has submitted the 2017 rate filings to CMS, the rates will not be finalized by federal CMS until October, 2016. Additionally, network and premium information will not be available until that time. The DOI announced that the rate information was published as early as possible to allow Illinois families to make better-informed decisions regarding health care coverage. The DOI acknowledged the rate increases as “a very difficult outcome for consumers.”

Rates

The average rate increase across all ratings areas for the lowest bronze plan is 44 percent. The rate change is lowest in Kane, Du Page, Will, and Kankakee counties, where the rate change is a 10 to 25 percent increase. Counties like Lake and Cook have a 40 to 60 percent increase, whereas counties including La Salle and McLean have a 20 to 40 percent increase for their lowest bronze plans.

The average rate increase across all ratings areas for the lowest silver plan is 45 percent. Counties like Cook and Kendall saw a 40 to 60 percent increase, whereas counties like Du Page, Sangamon, and McLean saw increases of 25 to 40 percent. The average rate increase across all ratings areas for the second lowest silver plan is 43 percent.

The highest average rate increase across all ratings areas is for the lowest gold plan—an increase of 55 percent. Although several counties do not have gold plan offerings, rate increases in some counties, including Peoria County, are as high as 60 to 70 percent. Rate increases for the lowest gold plan in counties like Cook, McLean and Sangamon are 40 to 60 percent.

In practical application, the new rates mean that a 21-year-old nonsmoker who purchases the lowest-priced silver plan in Cook County in 2017 could pay a premium of $221.13 a month—an increase from $152.42 a month in 2016. In Lake and McHenry counties the increases are more dramatic for the same consumer, $268.03 a month in 2017, up from $212.23 a month. However, for some, the rate increase is not as massive as it seems because 75 percent of Illinois exchange enrollees receive tax credits to offset premium costs.

Cause

The DOI attributed the rate increases to several factors, including the federal government’s failure to make payments to insurers promised as part of the ACA and an overall increase in medical and pharmaceutical costs. Additionally, the DOI pointed to the fact that, until 2017, policyholders are permitted to keep non-ACA compliant plans, a factor that the DOI said has harmed insurers’ risk pools and placed upward pressure on plan costs.