AHA raises concerns about proposed reductions in DSH allotments

The American Hospital Association (AHA) is urging CMS to delay the implementation of the fiscal year (FY) 2018 disproportionate share hospital (DSH) allotment reductions due to significant concerns about the data the agency proposed to use in the DSH Health Reform Methodology (DHRM), according to a letter sent to CMS Administrator Seema Verma. In addition, the AHA is continuing to advocate for the repeal of the Medicaid DSH reductions in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) (P.L. 111-148). The AHA noted that although Congress cut DSH payments based on its reasoning that hospitals would care for fewer uninsured patients as health care coverage expanded, the projected increase in coverage has not been fully realized. This is because some states chose not to expand Medicaid and there is lower-than-anticipated enrollment in health insurance coverage through the health insurance marketplace.

AHA raised two key issues within the Proposed rule: (1) the data sources used in the DHRM, with a focus on transparency, completeness, and timelines of the data; and (2) the proposed cap that would limit the reductions to only 90 percent of a state’s DSH allotment.

Background

Section 2551 of the ACA established that state Medicaid DSH allotments would be reduced annually in the aggregate in consideration of certain statutory factors. In 2013, CMS published a Final rule that finalized a methodology only for fiscal years (FY) 2014 and 2015 in anticipation of re-evaluation following implementation of the ACA (see CMS lays out methodology for Medicaid DSH reductions in 2014 and 2015, September 16, 2013).

Proposed rule

The Proposed rule reflects a DHRM that accounts for relevant data that was unavailable to CMS during prior rulemaking for DSH allotment reductions originally set to take place for FY 2014 and FY 2015 (see CMS proposes updated method to calculate ACA-mandated Medicaid allotment reductions, Health Law Daily, July. 28, 2017).

Data sources

According to the AHA,CMS plans to use its FY 2017 Medicaid DSH allotment determination, Medicaid Inpatient Utilization Rate (MIUR) data reported by states, and Medicaid DSH audit data reported by the states for state plan rate year 2013. AHA claims that because none of the listed sources are publicly available CMS cannot deliver on its intent to use transparent and readily available data. In addition, CMS has not provided states or stakeholders with the technical guidance on the calculations and data sources to be used as it indicated it would provide in its 2013 Final rule. AHA stressed that having accurate MIUR data is critical to ensuring states are treated equitably under the proposed formula and the delay in the data is a significant limitation to the accuracy of the methodology. The FY 2017 allotments are not expected to be made public until after the start of FY 2018, a further delay of information.

DSH allotment reduction cap

The AHA supports CMS’ proposal to cap DSH allotment reductions at 90 percent of a state’s allotment. The proposal would prevent any state from losing it entire DSH allotment and, therefore could receive an allotment after FY 2025, AHA said. However, AHA suggested that CMS consider a lower cap for the DSH allotment reductions because the number of states affected is likely to be small.